top of page
  • Writer's pictureMark Vogel

Prime Time Café in New Rochelle, New York: Kosher Dairy Takeout in Westchester County

Kosher dairy café in New Rochelle, New York

Prime Time Café in New Rochelle, New York
Prime Time Café in New Rochelle, New York

During a recent drive through downtown New Rochelle, New York, I found myself captivated by the artistic murals adorning the buildings. The creative street art added a lively character to the cityscape, reflecting the cultural richness of this Westchester County locale. My midday exploration worked up an appetite, prompting me to seek out a local spot for lunch. About ten minutes from the downtown area, I ventured to Prime Time Café, a kosher dairy takeout located at 1319 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10804.

“My visit to Prime Time Café was a delightful detour on my journey through New Rochelle. The falafel was a standout, offering a taste of authenticity in a city that celebrates its cultural diversity.”

Prime Time Café presents itself as a modest establishment, without the frills one might expect from dining venues in busier urban centers. Historically, this locale welcomed patrons to dine in; however, the pandemic has shifted its operation to exclusively takeout. The menu demonstrates the simplicity and appeal of dairy kosher cuisine, offering a wide range of options including pizza, pasta, and salads. Opting to try something from their menu that might be a bit less conventional, I chose the falafel.


The falafel at Prime Time Café was notably enjoyable. Despite the eatery's unassuming appearance, the flavors were authentic and satisfying, capturing the essence of traditional Middle Eastern fare. The falafel was perfectly cooked, with a crisp exterior giving way to a tender, flavorful interior. Each bite was a reminder of the café 's dedication to quality, even within the confines of a takeout operation.


Prime Time Café’s menu showcases a thoughtful selection of kosher dairy and vegetarian dishes, crafted to appeal to a range of palates. The salad options include a basic Tossed salad, alongside more specialized choices like Greek, Caesar, and Israeli salads, with a Sweet Greens salad available for those seeking a simpler option. Customers have the flexibility to enhance their salads with an additional scoop of tuna, providing a protein boost to their greens.


In the sandwiches category, the menu offers a variety of comforting classics and vegetarian delights. The grilled cheese sandwich stands as simple yet satisfying choice, with the option to add tomato to the for a slight variation. More substantial items include a tuna wrap, a veggie wrap, and a veggie burger, with the possibility to add cheese to any sandwich, catering to those in search of a more filling meal.


The sides section is a celebration of comfort food, featuring falafel balls, french fries, fried pickles, and a selection of other fried treats like ravioli, zucchini, mozzarella sticks, and onion rings. A potato knish is also available, offering a traditional option among the more indulgent fried dishes.


Pasta lovers will find a comforting range of options, from simple butter or marinara pastas to more decadent choices like Alfredo, vodka sauce, ravioli, baked ziti, stuffed shells, and lasagna. Each pasta dish is designed to ensure there's something for everyone at Prime Time Café.


New Rochelle is a city located in Westchester County, New York, approximately 20 miles northeast of Manhattan. This proximity makes it a popular choice for those looking to balance the hustle and bustle of New York City life with the more tranquil and spacious environment of the suburbs. New Rochelle's location along the Long Island Sound further enhances its appeal, offering scenic waterfront views and opportunities for various water-related activities.


The city has a rich history, dating back to its settlement by French Huguenots in 1688. This diverse heritage is reflected in the architectural variety found throughout the city, from historic 18th-century homes to modern high-rise apartments. Over the centuries, New Rochelle has grown from a small farming community into a bustling suburban city, boasting a population that is reflective of a broad cultural and socio-economic spectrum.


Downtown New Rochelle has undergone significant transformations, especially in recent years, with the development of new residential buildings, shops, restaurants, and cultural spaces. This area serves as the city's commercial and social hub, offering a variety of dining and entertainment options. The downtown revitalization efforts have been focused on making the area more pedestrian-friendly, with an emphasis on arts and culture, evident in the public art installations and murals that adorn the city streets.


Beyond the downtown area, New Rochelle is home to several neighborhoods known for their beautiful single-family homes, offering a range of architectural styles from classic Victorian to modern contemporary. Areas like Wykagyl, Beechmont, and Bonnie Crest are particularly notable for their spacious properties, lush landscapes, and sense of community. These neighborhoods provide a quieter, more residential atmosphere, making them ideal for families and individuals seeking a suburban lifestyle within close proximity to New York City.


With its blend of urban conveniences and suburban charm, rich history, and diverse community, New Rochelle presents a unique living experience for its residents. Its easy access to NYC via Metro-North Railroad, combined with the beauty of its natural surroundings and the vibrancy of its downtown area, continues to attract those looking for the best of both worlds.


New Rochelle boasts a significant Jewish community with a keen interest in kosher dining options. Despite this, the local area presents a limited selection of kosher establishments. This scarcity underscores the importance of places like Prime Time Café in serving the community's needs. Adjacent to Prime Time Café is Eden Wok, a kosher Chinese restaurant, providing a hint of culinary diversity within this niche. The presence of these eateries highlights the diverse palates catered to in New Rochelle, albeit on a smaller scale than one might hope.


The Jewish community in New Rochelle is engaged and contributes significantly to the cultural and spiritual fabric of the area. The city's kosher establishments are more than just dining options; they are gathering places that reflect and serve the community's values and dietary laws. The limited number of kosher venues suggests a potential for growth in this sector, catering to a population eager for diverse kosher culinary experiences.


My visit to Prime Time Café was a delightful detour on my journey through New Rochelle. The falafel was a standout, offering a taste of authenticity in a city that celebrates its cultural diversity. Hopefully, there will be more kosher options available in New Rochelle in the near future.


Recent Articles

bottom of page